M2M Comparison Page

M2M – SCADA Satcom Comparison (M2M – SCADA Comparison)
     vsat

Ku Broadband  

   hughes_bgan_open    

HNS 9201 M2M

        9502_M2M

HNS 9502 SCADA 

 ISDP

Skywave ISDP

  DMR_800  

Skywave DMR800

  Iridium_SBD_9522 

Iridium 9522B

 Iridium_SBD_9602 

Iridium 9602

Form Factor

Multi Unit Configuration with Coax Cable One Piece Design Two Piece Design with 10Meter separation between antenna and Transceiver One Piece Design One Piece Design Multi Piece requiring Multiple Antennas and Coax Cable Multi Piece design. Requires Integration work, multiple antennas

Overall Dimensions
Milimeters

+600mm 275 x 345 x 50

Antenna –          385 x 385 x 33   In Door Unit          200 x 150 x 45

127 x 127 x 50 160 (dia) x 47 (h) 162 x 81 x 28 (IDU only) 41 x 45 x 13 (IDU only)

Target
Monthly Usage

500MB 20 to 50MB Up to 15MB Up to 500KB Up to 10KB

Weight
(with Battery)

Variable Depending on system

2.8 kg

1.5kg (IDU)

1.9kg(Antenna/ODU)

0.46kg 0.5kg 0.42kg 3 grams

Interface Ports

Ethernet, USB, RS 232

Ethernet, USB, ISDN, WLAN (802.11b)

RJ 45, Ethernet

RS232, RS 485,     4 x Digital

RS232, RS 485

RS232, Control Audio,Analogue

RS232, GPS      (OEM Integrated)

Power Requirements

110-240 VAC 10-32 VDC

110-240 VAC

12-26 VDC

12 or 24 VDC 9-32 VDC 9-32 VDC 4.0 – 32 VDC

Power Consumption

Varries based on system

3.75W (idle)

24 W (oper)

<50mW (idle)

1 W (stby)

22 W (oper)

0.24 mW (stby)

10 W (oper)

0.24 mW (stby)

10 W (oper)

1.5W (stby)

4W (oper/call)

<1W (oper)

Operating
Temperature range

40°C to +60°C -25°C to +75°C w/o Batt-5°C to +55°C w/Batt -40°C to +75°C -40°C to +85°C -40°C to +85°C -30°C to +70°C -40°C to +85°C

Terminal Setup

Very fine Antenna pointing Plug and Play Easy Pointing Plug and Play Easy Pointing Omni Antenna Some Development Omni antenna, Requires Integration Developent Multiple Omni antennas, Requires Integration Developent Multiple Omni antennas, Requires Integration Developent

Services

Standard IP, Streaming IP, Voice

Standard IP, Streaming IP,Voice, Short Messaging, Asset Tracking

Standard IP, Streaming IP,Voice, SMS, Asset Tracking

IP, Store and Forward Packet Data Packet Data, Hybrid IP Packet Data, Hybrid IP

Transport Protocols

TCP/IP, UDP/IP, ISDN TCP/IP, UDP/IP, ISDN TCP/IP, UDP/IP, Store and forward Store and forward Store and forward Store and forward

Typical Performance

Up to 1Mbps Tx
Up to 4 Mbps Rx (all IP)

Up to 492 kbps (IP Tx)
Up to 492 kbps (IP Rx)
Up to 64kbps (ISDN)
32-384kbps (QOS)
Up to 100 kbps (IP Tx)
Up to 100 kbps (IP Rx)
6400 bytes send
10000 bytes receive
Up to 192 bytes send
Up to 100 bytes receive
Up to 1960 bytes send
Up to 1890 bytes receive
340 bytes send (Max)
270 bytes receive (Max)

Latency

650ms 900ms-1100ms 900ms – 1100ms

15-60 sec message size dependant

30 – 60 sec

5 sec 70 bytes
20 sec 1960 bytes

5 sec 70 bytes
20 sec 1960 bytes

Leave a Reply